Top 5 at 2014 Miss America Pageant [PHOTOS] 2014 Miss America Pageant top five Miss America 2014 and runners-up. First runner-up in the competition was Miss California, Crystal Lee who earned a $25,000 scholarship. Second runner-up was Miss Oklahoma, Kelsey Griswold. You might also like:Miss America Pageant contestants attend Blondie concertFans to Choose Miss Photogenic Teen USA at 2011 Miss Teen USA® PageantSponsor Goal is casting The Next Miss and Mr United Nationspageant fund raising2013 Miss America contestants are treated to a performance by ventriloquist Terry Fator at the MirageMs. / Mrs. Corporate America PageantMiss America 2013 Mallory Hagan visits Canada for the Calgary StampedeMiss America 2012 and Wisconsin Governor Promote Read to Lead ProgramMiss America’s Outstanding Teen performed at the 2012 Miss America Pageant.