Miss America Pageant Results 1954

1954 Miss America Pageant

Pageant Results > Miss America Pageant > 1954 Evelyn Ay

Evelyn Ay, Miss Pennsylvania, was crowned Miss America 1954 in September 1953 in Atlantic City by outgoing Miss America 1953, Neva Langley, of Georgia.

Evelyn Ay Miss America 1954
Evelyn Ay Miss America 1954, Miss Pennsylvania, was the last woman crowned in the pre-television era.

Ay was the last Miss America to be crowned in the pre-television era. A year later, she would become the first winner to crown her successor on live television.

Like her predecessor, Neva Langley, the 5' 8" Evelyn had a figure that was considered to be one of the finest ever to compete at the pageant, and she easily won the preliminary swimsuit competition.

The talent competition was another matter. Miss Pennsylvania's talent was to recite a poem she had memorized earlier that afternoon, "Leaves From my Grass House" -- which she had never bothered to practice out loud.* 

Ay was a hugely popular titleholder and a favorite with the public for decades after her reign due to her charm, friendliness and chatty personality. Frank Deford, author of the book, "There She Is: The Life and Times of Miss America", described Ay as "the girl who outtalked Billy Graham."

Unfortunately for any young man who might have the idea of romantically pursuing the popular queen, Ay was safely engaged to her college boyfriend, Navy Lieutenant Carl Sempier, a fellow student at the University of Pennsylvania.  Ay married the future IBM executive, shortly after giving up the title, and gave birth to their two daughters.

At the conclusion of her reign, the Ephrata, Pennsylvania native returned to Atlantic City for what was to be one of the most historic Miss America pageants of all... when the now beloved event was broadcast via television for enthralled viewers across the country to see live for the first time. As she took her final walk down the soon-to-be-famous Convention hall runway, she walked into history as the first Miss America ever to do so on live television.

At the close of the broadcast, Evelyn became part of an another pageant first when she crowned Miss California, Lee Meriwether, as Miss America 1955, making Lee the first queen to be crowned on live television.

This beloved Miss America died of colorectal cancer in 2008 at age seventy-five.

all Miss Americas

Sources: *"Miss America: In Pursuit of the Crown", www.lancasteronline.com

  • Miss America 1954: Evelyn Margaret Ay, Miss Pennsylvania
  • 1st runner-up: Joan Cecelia Kaible, Miss New York City
  • 2nd runner-up: Anne Lee Ceglis, Miss Virginia
  • 3rd runner-up: Virginia McDavid, Miss Alabama
  • 4th runner-up: Susanne Dugger, Miss Mississippi



View more pageant history | Miss America Pageant results by year
Opening  I  1920s  I  1930s  I  1940s I  1950s  I  1960s  I  1970s  I  1980s  I  1990s  I  2000s

Copyright, ©Pageant Center, 1998. All rights reserved. This material is fully protected by US copyright law. No content on this website can be reproduced or otherwise used without written permission from pageantcenter.com.
PageantCenter.com is not affiliated in any way with the Miss America Organization. Miss America® is a registered trademark of the Miss America Organization.

Pageant dates

Pageant Calendar
Find pageants near you
Add your pageant Free!
Free e-newsletter
Upcoming Pageants
Auditions/Casting Calls

Pageant Results
Miss World
Miss Universe
Miss America
Miss USA
Miss Teen USA
Miss Americas Teen

Pageant History

Pageant Winners
Major Titleholders
Miss America
Miss USA®
Miss Teen USA
Miss Universe®
Miss World
Mrs. World
Mrs. America
Miss America's Teen
Famous Winners
Titleholder Websites

Pageant News
Pageant News
Miss World News
Miss Universe® News
Miss America News
Miss USA® News
Miss Teen USA News
MAOTeen News
Casting Calls

Pageant History
Pageant Trivia
Fun Facts
Queens Life
Crowning Comedy
Quotable Quotes

Pageants to Enter
National - USA
All Pageants